GRE 作文题目 来源于朗播用户:chenya
[Claim] Knowing about the past cannot help people to make important decisions today. [Reason] We are not able to make connections between current events and past events until we have some distance from both. [Specific Task Instruction: Write a response in which you discuss the extent to which you agree or disagree with the claim and the reason on which that claim is based.]
题目分析
翻译
[观点]了解历史并不能够帮助人们在今天做出重要决定。 [理由]除非和二者都有一定的距离,否则我们无法将现在的事件和过去的事件联系起来。 [说明]写一篇文章,讨论你同意或反对这个观点,以及支持观点的理由达到怎样的程度。
指导
本题改编自老GRE的ISSUE54"History teaches us only one thing: knowing about the past cannot help people to make important decisions today"。题目讨论历史作用,尤其是历史在为现在的人们提供参考帮助上面的作用,给出的理由类似于“不识庐山真面目,只缘身在此山中”。题目不难,而且历史类话题素材广泛。但是写作的时候要注意一点:不要简单说一句历史还有其他作用,然后就花大篇幅去论述其他作用(岔开话题)。因为本题后半部分的“distance”同样是审题以及论述的重点。
1. 在你的印象中,过去的生活和现在的生活之间有哪些差距?今天有哪些事物是过去没有的?哪些事物一直存在,但是和过去相比,在内涵上发生了改变?请举例并简述。
回答: 现在科技发展迅速,使得交通系统更加发达,各种通信手段(手机,电脑)便利,还有媒体传播信息,医疗技术更加先进,都是过去没有的。但是许多传统节日、习俗,只是人们过节的方式可能发生了变化,比如春节,以前一般都是坐在家里吃团圆饭看电视,现在很多家庭选择利用这个时间出去旅游迎接新年。还有人与人之间的交流互动一直存在,但是方式发生了变化,以前大部分是面对面交流或者书面文字交流,现在更多的是用手机、在网上(email、视频会议)交流,或者通过facebook、twitter等SNS平台进行新鲜事的分享。
2. 历史对于现在的人们的影响和意义主要体现在哪些方面?影响方式有哪些?人们参考历史的目的是什么?请举例并简述。
回答: 历史对于现在人们的影响在“成功经验的借鉴”和“失败教训的吸取”两大方面。通过教科书或史料记载,小说,电影等文学体裁的反应以及媒体报道,网络宣传,舆论传播,社会潮流等影响我们。 历史可以传承好的文化思想,比如传统美德的传承(诚信、孝顺),一些治国方略,比如仁爱、亲民之类。 PS:老杜等一些大牛成功的创业经历给了我们这一代年轻人很多正能量,鼓励更多有思想的年轻人追求自己的梦想,同时也能为社会的发展注入新鲜血液。人们参考历史以求进步。 同时历史上的失败可以作为一种警戒和教训,使现在的人吸取教训,比如历史上封建制度的失败告诉人们这个行不通。再如现在产品销量全球领先的苹果公司在早期也是有一些销售失败的产品,如Lisa等很多产品都是因为公司管理制度动荡和产品造价过高等原因没有得到支持,无法与IMB等巨头的产品竞争,期间公司差一点破产,后来JOBS回归苹果之后吸取以往的经验教训改革管理制度,设计出性价比高的iMAC系列产品,红遍全球。
3. 是不是只有和现在完全一样的历史事件才会对今天的生活有指导意义?如果不是?那么怎样的事情是有指导意义的?请举例说明。
回答: 不是。历史是否具有指导意义在于人们怎样理解和看待,更在于人们是否有足够的敏感度去认识到其重要性,从而指导实践。孙子兵法里讲了很多古代用兵打仗的一些谋略,古今中外的军事家们都使用其中论述的军事理论来指导战争,而且,其中论述的基本理论和思想还被运用到了现代经营决策和社会管理方面,甚至还可以用到日常生活当中。如欲擒故纵、声东击西的方法,可以运用到许多体育比赛项目中,先想办法让对手放松警惕,趁其不备再加以打击。抛砖引玉的方法被许多老师借鉴,在课堂上给出话题,引导学生发散思维,课堂互动效率更高。(这个好不好表达呢)
4. 对于处于当下状况下的某件事,人们能否进行正确并且理性的分析?如果遇到了和以前某件事情类似的情况,能否借用以前的经验?应该如何借用?请分析并简述。
回答: 人们不一定能够正确且理性地分析。缺乏足够的专业知识和敏感性,甚至对社会历史事件不够关注都会造成人不能正确认识进而理性全面地分析。即使碰到了类似的事件,也不能盲目套用过去的经验。要充分考虑到历史因素,客观环境以及地理位置,具体情况等一系列问题。大的方面:比如经济危机的应对策略,现在的经济形势和引起经济危机的原因与以前不同。小的方面:以前的很多人出国留学之后发展都很好,但是现在的我们再决定是否出国之前要考虑自己的能力、家庭状况以及专业方向和今后的发展道路等很多方面的因素,而不能只因为以前的人说好就出国。
其他用户的回答
作文
I concede that sometimes we may make wrong decisions only relied on the history, however, one cannot deny that the extant and close links between the old and new events may lead us to think and act more considerately. If we can learn more information about the past and rationally analysis the present situation, some experience from success and lessons from failure will be useful for us to make important choices or decisions.
Events happened in the past might different from present events for the changes of time and space. Sometimes we are not able to evaluate the points of history appropriately since that may be too old for us to understand all the details. In addition, we may also be confused by current situations in which we are involved. Using the past experience to deal with current things without any change or prudent consideration, a person would make some inadvisable decisions. Take one's determination about studying abroad for an example. If a student decide to study abroad only for the previous success of his or her friends who have studied abroad, they may be failed to compare his or her own conditions with the others', such as the ability of learning, the family economic levels and their future working plans related to their major. Thus, their reckless decisions about going abroad may be irresponsible for themselves as well as their families.
In fact, we can also see many successful current decisions that are all based on the lessons from reviewing past events. Apple company, for example, had some unsuccessful products in its early competition with other companies, such as Microsoft and IBM, despite its current popularity all over the world. Today's success can be mostly attributed to the leader's changing of the management systems and reducing of the costs of their amazing products, and such improved decisions are based on their objectively facing their previous failure and preventing it when deciding the current marketing strategy. Additionally, we can learn about the history and ancient events according to movies, books and mass medias to make us familiar with them. We may not aware that many good habits and customs we have today are influenced by previous people or ideas. A good example is that we share strong concentrations on our families and communities, which is inherited from Confucianism.
In order to avoid lopsidedness when we decide according to the past experience, we need to be objective and rational to regard current things as if we stand at the point which have distance from both the past and the present. The Art of War, a very famous book about battle strategies in ancient China, is a very useful direction for leaders to learn how to fight with wisdom. Although today there are less wars than before, these valuable principles in the book can also be extended to our daily life to deal with complicated matters in political and business world. And one can make full use of the old techniques on fights in their current life or work only after they are clear about the differences and similarities between their own situation and the past one. If not so, applying previous methods to present conditions may be somewhat dangerous.
In a nutshell, based on the above discussions, I draw the conclusion that whether an ancient event can be used by us to deal with our present problems is based on our objectivity and rationality when considering complex situations. The idea that fully repudiates the importance of history on our decision making turns out to be unreasonable. If we can learn more information about the past and rationally analysis the present situation, the past things may become very useful directions for us to decide our choices.
写作指导
写作指导启发思路,积累素材,有效解决写作没思路、没素材的问题。
观看名师讲解,边看边学!
轻松扫一扫,有趣又有料
10G 托福视频教程分享群
374897650
10G GRE 视频教程分享群
305634398

请选择发起聊天的方式:

安装 QQ